Indianapolis Food & Drink

Scoops of Joy: 13 Must-Try Ice Cream Shops in Indianapolis!

Are you looking for the best ice cream in Indianapolis? Look no further! This city is filled with ice cream shops that offer a wide range of flavors and styles.

Whether you prefer classic vanilla or adventurous flavors like lavender honey or goat cheese and fig, there is an ice cream shop in Indianapolis that will satisfy your cravings.

From small mom-and-pop shops to large chains, Indianapolis has it all. Each shop has its unique atmosphere and menu, making it an adventure to explore them all.

Some shops use locally sourced ingredients, while others experiment with international flavors. Regardless of what you are looking for, there is an ice cream shop in Indianapolis that will fit your taste.

One of the best things about ice cream is that it is the perfect treat for any occasion. You can grab a cone on a hot summer day, celebrate a special occasion with a sundae, or enjoy a pint of your favorite flavor while watching a movie at home.

With so many options in Indianapolis, you can enjoy the perfect scoop of ice cream no matter what your mood or occasion. So come on, let's explore the best ice cream shops in Indianapolis!

1. Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream

Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream
9922 E 79th St, Indianapolis, IN 46256 (Google Maps)

Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream is a top-notch ice cream shop that serves up addicting flavors. The staff is friendly, and the prices are reasonable.

The shop has an old parlor feel, and the owners give back to the community through fundraisers.

They also offer catering services, which are highly recommended.

If you're in the area, be sure to stop in and try their Almond Joy flavor or one of their coffee beverages. You won't be disappointed!

2. Chris' Ice Cream and Mexican Food

Chris' Ice Cream And Mexican Food
1484 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240 (Google Maps)

Chris' Ice Cream and Mexican Food is a family-friendly restaurant that offers a variety of Mexican comfort food and an array of ice cream flavors.

The ice cream is handmade and has a unique texture that is unlike any other ice cream.

The tacos are a must-try and are some of the best in town. The staff is friendly and provides fast service.

Chris' Ice Cream and Mexican Food is a great spot for a casual meal with friends or family.


901 E 64th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220 (Google Maps)

BRICS is a charming ice cream shop located in an ex-train depot. They offer an impressive variety of unique flavors that are deliciously made with top-quality ingredients.

The customer service is excellent and the staff is always attentive and helpful.

BRICS also has a full side area of vegan ice cream options. The price is on the higher end, but it's worth it for the small business aspect and overall experience.

If you're looking for a refreshing treat on a hot day or a sweet ending to a meal, BRICS is definitely worth a visit.

4. LiftOff Creamery

Liftoff Creamery
111 E 16th St #105, Indianapolis, IN 46202 (Google Maps)

LiftOff Creamery is an ice cream shop that offers premium ice cream with a wide variety of unique flavors.

Their friendly staff provides excellent service and gives out samples to help customers find their favorite flavors.

The cozy atmosphere and aviation-themed decor make for a fun experience.

They also offer shaved ice on the menu. LiftOff Creamery is a great place to satisfy your sweet tooth.

5. Graeter's Ice Cream

Graeter's Ice Cream
5560 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46208 (Google Maps)

Graeter's Ice Cream is a small-batch ice cream parlor chain that serves up some of the best scoops around. Their signature sundaes and frozen drinks are not to be missed either.

With a wide variety of flavors available, there's something for everyone. The chocolate chip cookie dough is particularly noteworthy, with rich chocolate that takes it to another level.

The staff is pleasant and the shop is clean and artistic, with an old-school ice cream parlor feel.

While the line can get long and the parking can be a hassle on busy days, the delicious ice cream is worth the wait and effort. Graeter's is definitely a must-visit for any ice cream lover.

6. CRAVE Ice Cream Social

Crave Ice Cream Social
11691 Fall Creek Rd #115, Indianapolis, IN 46256 (Google Maps)

CRAVE Ice Cream Social is a must-visit ice cream shop for those who love creamy and flavorful treats.

This intimate bistro offers a great selection of frozen treats, including dairy-free options. The staff is friendly and welcoming, making the experience even more enjoyable.

The outdoor seating area is perfect for summertime visits, and the large parking lot makes it easy to stop by.

Whether you're in the mood for classic flavors or more unique ones, CRAVE Ice Cream Social has something for everyone.

7. Nicey Treat

Nicey Treat
916 E Westfield Blvd, Indianapolis, IN 46220 (Google Maps)

Nicey Treat is a must-visit for anyone who loves ice cream.

They offer a wide variety of dairy-based and vegan popsicles with unique flavors that are perfect for a hot summer day. The staff is friendly and the service is fast.

Although the seating is limited, the ice cream is well worth the visit.

The prices are a bit steep, but the quality of the ingredients justifies it. Nicey Treat is definitely worth checking out if you're in the area.

8. Scoop Shack

Scoop Shack
7002 Lake Plaza Dr suite b, Indianapolis, IN 46220 (Google Maps)

Scoop Shack is a local ice cream shop with a wide variety of flavors and treats.

They even offer snacks for dogs! The staff is friendly and the shop is clean.

Customers can enjoy coloring pages and games while they indulge in their ice cream.

If you're an ice cream lover, give Scoop Shack a try.

9. Square Scoop

Square Scoop
1028 Virginia Ave Suite 100, Indianapolis, IN 46203 (Google Maps)

Square Scoop is an ice cream shop that offers a variety of hand-packed ice cream flavors. The shop is known for its unique and distinctive flavors like graham central station and banana cream pie.

The staff is friendly and accommodating, especially when it comes to dietary restrictions.

They offer gluten-free and lactose intolerant options, which are clearly labeled on the menu. The prices are a bit high, but the portions are generous and worth the price.

The decor is simple and retro, with lots of old-fashioned candy available for sale. Square Scoop is a great place to stop by for a sweet treat and a nostalgic experience.

10. Howdy Homemade Ice Cream

Howdy Homemade Ice Cream
370 N New Jersey St, Indianapolis, IN 46204 (Google Maps)

Howdy Homemade Ice Cream is a brand-new ice cream shop that has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

They offer delicious flavors, fresh waffle cones, and friendly service.

What sets Howdy Homemade apart is their mission: the shop is staffed almost entirely by employees with special needs, and all profits go toward supporting job training and employment for individuals with disabilities.

So, indulge in some of the best ice cream around while supporting a good cause at Howdy Homemade Ice Cream!

11. Ritter's Frozen Custard

Ritter's Frozen Custard
4949 E Stop 11 Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46237 (Google Maps)

Ritter's Frozen Custard is a dessert chain that serves up cones, sundaes, and shakes. They make their frozen custard fresh daily, ensuring that customers get a delicious and creamy treat every time.

With a variety of flavors to choose from, Ritter's Frozen Custard has something for everyone.

The outdoor seating area is clean and well-maintained, making it a great place to enjoy a sweet treat on a warm day.

The service is fast and friendly, making for a pleasant experience overall. For a casual stop for a range of sweet treats, be sure to check out Ritter's Frozen Custard.

12. Wyliepalooza Ice Cream & Anime

Wyliepalooza Ice Cream & Anime
7 Johnson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219 (Google Maps)

Wyliepalooza Ice Cream & Anime is a quirky and fun ice cream shop that offers a variety of unique flavors.

With a colorful interior and a collection of anime and Japanese-related products, this shop has a fun atmosphere. In addition to ice cream, they also offer bubble tea and milkshakes.

The staff is friendly and willing to give out samples. Although the seating area is limited, the shop has board games and old-style arcade games to keep customers entertained.

Wyliepalooza Ice Cream & Anime is definitely worth a visit for anyone looking for a fun and tasty dessert spot.

13. The New Age of Ice Cream & More LLC

The New Age Of Ice Cream & More Llc
1325 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203 (Google Maps)

The New Age of Ice Cream & More LLC is a must-visit for ice cream lovers.

They offer a wide variety of flavors and vegan options, all made fresh on site. Not only is the ice cream delicious, but the presentation is beautiful.

The shop also serves hot beverages, crepes, and tamales. The staff is friendly and the shop is clean.

Whether you're looking for a sweet treat or a dairy-free option, The New Age of Ice Cream & More LLC has got you covered.